CRC-VALUE calculation question - Forum - OpenEdge General - Progress Community

CRC-VALUE calculation question


CRC-VALUE calculation question

This question is not answered

Scenario, using git and bamboo (CI) code is effectively in two directories.
When compiled a small number of our sources are generating different crc, and therefore md5, values - around 1-2% of sources.

Any thought on why?
db's are the same, sources are not changed - just different directory.
I know the filename is part of the crc-value calc BUT if the path was involved surely all our files would get differect crc-values rather than just this small amount

All Replies
  • Maybe you are confusing rcode-info:crc-value with rcode-info:table-crc-list

    crc-value is a number for the .r file, what is changed even with a different directory.

    table-crc-list is the same number for table crc which it was compiled

  • I understand the difference and am also using the table-crc-list but when using the MD5 or crc-value I'm noticing that a small number of files that shouldn't be flagged as changed are.

    What I cant understand is if the directory where the source or rcode is matters why isnt it all files.

  • Yeah, I don't know. But I don't recommend to use the CRC to identify changes. For example, I have 164 thousand .r files in the system. Hundreds of these .r files have the same CRC value, but the code is completely different. There is a chance that you change a program and it generates the same CRC. It's not easy, but it's possible.

  • Some time back I was also looking into CRC and MD5 checksums. For some unexplained reason the CRC checksum was not as good as the MD5, i.e. I got different CRC checksums on the same file but no source code was changed. Using the MD5 seems to be a better choice - but then you need to compile with the GENERATE-MD5 option.

    However I was never able to find a good reason why the CRC would change but the MD5 stays the same.

  • the reason CRC is not as good as MD5 is because CRC was designed for a completely different purpose, namely to detect certain types of transmission errors in data communications. in such uses, the CRC is computed over a relatively small block of data (up to a few thousand bytes). differing inputs can quite normally result in the same checksum values, especially when the data blocks are too large. this makes it it unsuitable for detecting identical or changed files.

  • So why would a CRC change but the MD5 stays the same with exactly the same source code?

  • CRC will change based on DB schema changes but the MD5 will not.

  • > On Aug 16, 2018, at 5:26 AM, jbijker wrote:


    > So why would a CRC change but the MD5 stays the same with exactly the same source code?


    you have not actually explained how you obtain either of these values so i cannot say why the CRC differs and MD5 does not.